Crystal clear: using neutrons to tackle a fundamental biotechnological challenge
ILL's instruments play a crucial role in disentangling complex protein crystallisation pathways.
The crystallisation of proteins is a double-edged sword. If it occurs in an uncontrolled manner in pharmaceutical formulations or in the human body, it can compromise the efficacy of the formulation or cause severe disease, respectively. At the same time, getting proteins to crystallise in vitro is an essential prerequisite for the elucidation of protein structures - and a difficult one, too. Crystallisation assays are often a tedious undertaking relying on trial and error and systematic, simplified approaches are difficult to establish.
One possibility to induce crystallisation in a controlled manner is to add certain substances to protein solutions. A case in point are polymers and charged molecules or atoms. In particular, multivalent salt ions (carrying more than one electric charge) have been shown to be efficient promoters of protein crystallisation.
A team of ILL researchers and their collaborators from Tübingen (Germany) and Lund (Sweden) used a multimethod approach to obtain detailed insights into the pathways underlying the crystallisation of the protein human serum albumin (HSA) in the presence of the multivalent ion La3+. "Already in the first assays using optical microscopy and small-angle neutron scattering (SANS), we were excited to see that even tiny differences in La3+ concentration drastically altered the crystal structure we obtained", says Christian Beck, the first author of the team's newest publication. "This motivated us to perform further experiments on this intriguingly sensitive system."
The team went on to characterise their HSA-La3+ samples in real-time, starting from isolated protein molecules in solution up to large crystalline assemblies. To this end, the researchers exploited a large variety of the ILL's instrument suite.

Image: Length- and time-scales accessible to neutrons, compared to other experimental methods.
Quasielastic neutron scattering and neutron spin echo allowed for distinguishing the molecular motions of protein molecules in solution and those within crystals. "As protein crystal precursors are formed, the solution is depleted of fast-moving small isolated proteins. Therefore we observed an overall slowing down of protein diffusion over time", explains Tilo Seydel, co-author of the study and co-responsible of ILL's spectrometer IN16B. Interestingly, this behaviour is markedly different from that of a rather similar protein-salt system (beta-lactoglobulin from bovine milk and the divalent ion Cd2+). In the latter, the protein molecules slow down initially to assemble into a gel-like crystal precursor before speeding up again as the crystal grows, depleting the surrounding solution of protein.
For both protein-salt systems, the experiments revealed that protein diffusion in solution and continuous, slow structural evolution of the precursors and, eventually, crystals determine the crystallisation process. These studies therefore reflect the inherent complexity of the biophysical pathways underlying protein crystallisation.
"Thanks to the outstanding energy resolution of ILL's instruments, very rich information that is crucial to such fundamental studies of intricated biological processes can be obtained within a few hours of experimental time", says Christian Beck. This project also highlights the outstanding complementarity of ILL instruments, which notably allows for studies of both static and energy-resolved parameters of users' samples. Looking beyond purely fundamental research, this neutron-based knowledge is of outstanding importance for pharmacological and medical applications.
Several Master and PhD students participated in the numerous experiments for this investigation, illustrating the ILL's commitment towards training young researchers. The authors gratefully acknowledge these precious opportunities. Moreover, the authors greatly benefited from the Partnership for Soft Condensed Matter (PSCM) on the EPN campus.
ILL instruments: D33, IN11A (no longer in operation), IN16B, WASP
ILL contacts: Orsolya Czakkel, Bela Farago, Olga Matsarskaia (now at Université Grenoble-Alpes/CHU Grenoble), Sylvain Prévost, Tilo Seydel
Reference: Beck, C., Mosca, I., Miñarro, L. M., Sohmen, B., Buchholz, C., Maier, R., ... & Seydel, T. (2025). A multiscale in situ time-resolved study of the nano-to millisecond structural dynamics during protein crystallization. Applied Crystallography, 58(3). http://dx.doi.org/10.1107/S160057672500353X